Comments on: American Airlines Triumphs Over United For Prime Tokyo Haneda Airport Slot, Adds New York Service https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/ Thought Leader in Travel Mon, 29 Jan 2024 14:26:23 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.4.2 By: Arnaud https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5663341 Mon, 29 Jan 2024 14:26:23 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5663341 @TimDunn….
UA is not growing to Europe? Then what is EWR-FAO, ORD-ATH, SFO-BCN? UA did the bulk of their major TA expansion two seasons ago. DL has catch up to do, if they can.
When you count SEA AND LAX as West coast hubs, surely you can’t disrespect UA @ LAX.
LAX-LHR, NRT, HND, HKG, SYD, AKL, MEL. Once the IGW 787s are on property, you’ll see more adds, including PVG.
All of your points assume UA will stand still while DL has their way. Not so.
The internal numbers for future increases via the West coast are stunning.
It’s disingenuous to say the 787s are the problem to the suspended routes. If there wasn’t a war in Ukraine and if there wasn’t a war in Israel, most routes would be operating. I recall that DL’s A350s have issues in JNB and that’s why DL is running triangles via CPT instead of nonstop.
Your green-eyed envy of UA is so evident with your daily rants.

]]>
By: UAsucks https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5662055 Sun, 28 Jan 2024 06:47:50 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5662055 I love to see UA lose

]]>
By: Jim https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661977 Sun, 28 Jan 2024 00:48:57 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661977 PHl has service to 18 European cities. I see no reason it cannot capture one asia route.

]]>
By: Tim Dunn https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661972 Sun, 28 Jan 2024 00:26:35 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661972 and I will say that I enjoy discussing w/ Mark more than just about anyone on the internet.
We have very different ideas but he is articulate and polite.
I can only wish there were more aviation chat participants like him.

]]>
By: Tim Dunn https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661962 Sun, 28 Jan 2024 00:04:02 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661962 AA’s lack of maintenance – which Gary regularly writes about – doesn’t change the economics of operating the plane.
It does cheapen the product but can and does happen on every aircraft type.

And one more tidbit. DL now operates more flights from ATL, DTW, and MSP to East Asia than UA does from EWR and IAD – 2 from ATL growing to 3 this summer – and 2.5 from DTW – HND, ICN and 3 day/week PVG and 2 from MSP which happens to be to two cities while UA from ORD is just to 2 airports in Tokyo.
DL always was larger in the eastern US than UA and now that trend is spreading to include Asia.
That reality is not lost on UA execs.

]]>
By: M https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661954 Sat, 27 Jan 2024 23:43:04 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661954 Aside from Tim Dunn lectures….

Last week flew AA J LAX-HND 787
No IFE
Auto window shade didn’t tint so being on the left side I had sun streaming into the cabin at my seat. And I was told to write to Boeing
When I complained via the app, I was thanked for flying their “world class airline”
When I complained about their “world class airline” a second time I was awarded 7,500 miles.

]]>
By: Tim Dunn https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661947 Sat, 27 Jan 2024 23:29:25 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661947 A few factors you might consider, Mark, when you and others talk about all of this international growth you think UA will do:
1. Limitations due to treaties and bilaterals. We have discussed China and Japan and the fact that S. Korea really does have legitimate Open Skies while Japan does not allow it at HND, the airport with the greatest revenue per flight. UA isn’t going to add flights to KIX or NRT although there is Open Skies there.
2. Limitations due to Russian airspace closures and other no-fly zones for US airlines. Although you love to talk about SFO, the reality is that most of UA’s transpacific routes from the eastern US to East Asia outside of Japan don’t work due to flight time. There is only so many flights UA can add from the west coast to compensate for its inability to operate from the East Coast to deep E. Asia.
3. Limitations of the 787. As you know, UA dropped EWR-BOM and DEL to everywhere except for EWR because of a combination of #2 and the 787’s limitations. DL says they can make BOM work and they are likely right given that SQ overflies India on the way from JFK/EWR to SIN and they don’t even use the most capable A350s.
DL flies DTW-PVG and it is hitting 16 hours on a regular basis in the winter and even longer on some days – and DL is not using the most capable A350s. UA can probably fly EWR-PVG but will have to payload restrict on some days. On DEL-EWR, on days the flight exceeds 16.5 hours, the flight is never full.
If UA has to compete with a 787 with 230 or fewer seats vs. DL using an A350 with 275 seats – their newer more premium configuration on the most capable A350-900s, the economics will simply not favor UA operating profitably.
Because of Russian airspace restrictions, flights to PEK now take longer than to PVG which means that EWR-PEK and IAD-PEK and perhaps ORD-PEK will not work unless UA consistently sells 80% of their 265 seat B787-9 for 5 months a year. Given that DL and UA pay the same salaries to pilots, having 40-50 less passengers on a UA 787 vs a DL A350 is not a recipe for financial success.
UA will run out of routes it can operate using its pre-covid allocations before DL will and will be forced to petition the DOT for a route case to allocate any new routes which makes it unlikely UA will retain the advantage it once had.

The reality is that all of this growth that you and others think will come to UA is simply not possible to the destinations and on the routes that UA flew even 5 years ago while DL will be much more capable of serving those routes with the A350-900 and economics will be even better on the A350-1000 on routes that can justify that kind of capacity – which will be similar to the UA 777-300ER but at much lower operating costs.

UA’s rapid growth wasn’t sustainable as soon as DL started growing w/ much more efficient and capable aircraft; Russian, Middle East and Ukraine airspace closures plus treaty limitations combined w/ the limits of the 787 cut the number of routes dramatically.

]]>
By: Tim Dunn https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661778 Sat, 27 Jan 2024 18:19:08 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661778 My reference to SYD was from LAX. DL is the only carrier that is operating double daily.
I know UA is larger to most of the Pacific but every time you and others tout SFO you fail to note that DL is growing both SEA and LAX across the Pacific.

UA is not going to get any advantage to China because the DOT is allowing AA, DL and UA to each get equal amounts of frequencies UNTIL they are all back to their pre-covid allocations and what the treaty allows. No one realistically expects China to reopen all frequencies because they had to subsidize their carriers in order to support the number of flights they had pre-covid and the Chinese are not going to allow US carriers to carry a higher percentage of flights than Chinese carriers.

In Japan, Korea, and China, DL and UA are the same size and DL will overtake UA. DL is adding flights elsewhere in Asia besides those 3 countries and will continue to do so.

As hard as it is for you to accept, UA’s dominance of the Pacific will be cut.
And DL is growing its Pacific with much more cost efficient aircraft.

The reason why UA is not growing its Atlantic this year is because they know that DL made considerably more money flying slightly less capacity. DL has been more profitable flying the Pacific with less capacity. UA simply cannot continue to pursue growth when it can’t deliver margins as high as DL and while adding debt.
Once again, DL retired billions in debt in 2023 and had $2 billion in free cash flow while UA is burning cash even w/ its reduced number of aircraft deliveries.
DL spent $1.5 billion less on fuel than UA in 2023 and generated more revenue and $2 billion more in profits.

DL has the best formula for international growth and they will use it.

]]>
By: Mark https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661756 Sat, 27 Jan 2024 17:55:05 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661756 @Tim, UA would serve HND from GUM using a nighttime slot that wouldn’t work from anywhere else. DL is using a daytime slot for HNL.

DL is the largest US carrier to SYD? UA is double daily from SFO while also serving LAX and IAH. That’s four flights to SYD.

UA has also said the additional 787s coming online, starting this year, will be used to rebuild China. DL is only even with UA to China (assuming you exclude HKG, which makes UA significantly bigger) due to artificial constraints. The UA hubs are much better suited for Asia flying, especially SFO that doesn’t have the fierce international competition in LAX or the relatively low O&D in SEA.

]]>
By: Lower Fare Lady https://viewfromthewing.com/american-airlines-triumphs-over-united-for-prime-tokyo-haneda-airport-slot-adds-new-york-service/comment-page-1/#comment-5661738 Sat, 27 Jan 2024 17:37:56 +0000 https://viewfromthewing.com/?p=199255#comment-5661738 Thanks for the article! I hope this addition of daily operations between JFK and Tokyo will prompt the tix prices to go down.

Pre-pandemic, direct flights for this route in J were typically in the $4.5K to $5K range, but the same tix have been stuck in the $8k range for some time now. I personally attribute it to the fact that ANA and JAL are the only viable options out of JFK to Tokyo (UA uses EWR; DL, w/o a Japanese alliance partner, isn’t always a good choice for passengers that reside in Japan).

]]>